Menu Bar
Needs Plugin: Flash
How Did the Universe Begin?
Presented by Stephen Hawking, this short documentary takes a look at the origin of the universe as understood by modern science.
Jan 20, 2008 5:35 AM
Re: How Did the Universe Begin?
Fascinating, but I found the explanation that the universe was spontaneously created from nothing to be largely unsatisfying. It seems almost too easy, I always thought it to be possible that we are even infinitely smaller than previously thought and our universe is simply a pocket of heat in an ever larger space outside of the boundaries of our universe.
Simply put, there very well could have been another contributing factor (maybe an outside source of disturbance) in the big bang that we will never be able to observe because of our relative size to everything else in the cosmos.
Simply put, there very well could have been another contributing factor (maybe an outside source of disturbance) in the big bang that we will never be able to observe because of our relative size to everything else in the cosmos.
By: Shiggety
Re: How Did the Universe Begin?
there's a theory that 'existence' is like a blanket on a clothesline, and that there are an infinite number of blankets hanging alongside one another. and that some force, like a breeze, caused one blanket to come into contact with ours, and that caused the big bang and our universe. and it's possible the same two 'blankets' are in contact with each other in multiple locations, and also with multiple blankets causing an infinite number of universes. i read about it popular science a couple years ago.
i agree the spontaneous creation from absolutely nothing just doesn't do it for me. also, isn't that pretty much against the laws of science to begin with? despite their little boiling water steam bubble analogy which i found pretty weak.
i agree the spontaneous creation from absolutely nothing just doesn't do it for me. also, isn't that pretty much against the laws of science to begin with? despite their little boiling water steam bubble analogy which i found pretty weak.
By: macgregor
Re: How Did the Universe Begin?
Sounds like you're refering to the Steinhardt Turok theory of cyclic "big bangs."
see: http://www.spacedaily.com/news/cosmology-02c.html
see: http://www.spacedaily.com/news/cosmology-02c.html
By: lobstersnail
Re: How Did the Universe Begin?
i beleive they spoke of observational evidence on spontaneously created matter and antimatter in Atom: The illusion of reality. however, i think it was made up by a guy who worked in a paint plant, so it might have been the fumes.
By: bloorgg
Re: How Did the Universe Begin?
Everything we observe in the universe is either part of or the result natural reactions. Species don't just appear and atoms don't just arrange themselves.
My point is what was the natural event that caused the big bang? As I said before, things don't 'just happen'. If it was not a natural event it must've been supernatural, that's why I'm a deist.
My point is what was the natural event that caused the big bang? As I said before, things don't 'just happen'. If it was not a natural event it must've been supernatural, that's why I'm a deist.
By: SaladDays
Re: How Did the Universe Begin?
We may never know what the natural event that caused the Big Bang was (I believe it has something to do with the type of compression that we observe in stars), but falling back on a supernatural explanation is essentially giving up on your own intelligence. "God did it" is too simple an answer for many people in this day in age but conversely it was the best answer for those who wrote the bible/koran/other doctrines because of their lack of knowledge of scientific principles.
By: Shiggety
Re: How Did the Universe Begin?
Overall, I find the big bang theory unsatisfying. I prefer the idea that matter has always existed and will always exist. I think that fits along with the concepts of science much better than the thought that we came out of nothing. And I also believe that the universe and all existence is infinitly large. Size is relative, our universe seems big and an atom seems small, but that's only due to our relative position in size. I think that we can not fathom existence just like how we can not fathom infinity.
By: Wonderr
Re: How Did the Universe Begin?
The very notion of infinity I find endlessly fascinating. The universe might be a (relatively tiny) bubble in an ocean of bubbles in an ocean of bubbles in an ocean of bubbles ad infinitum ...
By: White_Wolf
Re: How Did the Universe Begin?
Well, just don't fall into the 'big and small infinities' rut Georg Cantor was in. You'd think zooming in/out on the original circle would come to people's minds, but no, they have to think 'bigger circle, littler circle'. 8)
http://www.milkandcookies.com/link/81195/
http://www.milkandcookies.com/link/81195/
By: Jiachi


